Seeft
September 30, 2026

How a $140M drinks brand got $2.6M back from distributor billbacks and retailer deductions

Illustrative case. The company and the figures are composites, representative of accounts in this segment.

Identified
$3.95M
2.8% of revenue
Returned within 12 months
$2.6M
Disputable billbacks
7%
Down from 22%
Mehdi Amara · Co-founder and CEO

At a glance

Profile
The brandMarlow Beverage, teas and sparkling waters
Revenue$140M a year
Sells through58 distributors and six grocery chains
Billbacks$11.2M a year, about 1,680 lines a month
Retailer deductions$3.9M a year
What we checked12 months of billbacks, deductions and co-packer invoices

The problem

Marlow Beverage sells teas and sparkling waters through 58 distributors and six grocery chains. Nine sales managers agree promotions with distributors and buyers by email, and there is no trade promotion system. Distributors bill back $11.2M of allowances a year, calculated on their own arithmetic from their own depletion reports, and retailers deduct another $3.9M from remittances.

Checking one billback meant finding four documents in three places: the program letter in a sales manager's inbox, the depletion report in the distributor's portal, the state price file on a shared drive and the billback itself in AR. That took about 45 minutes a line. One accountant could review the 80 lines a month above $10K. The other 1,600 went to sales, who confirmed them from memory, and the credit was issued.

Retailer deductions got even less attention. AR matched each one to a reason code and accepted most of them, because pulling a signed proof of delivery from the 3PL took longer than the deduction was worth.

What the check involved

Seeft connected to the places the evidence already lived. Nothing had to be rebuilt first.

  • Promotions: the sales team's email, where every program letter and buyer agreement for the year was found and read
  • Billbacks and depletions: the distributors' portals and the spreadsheets they send each month
  • Prices: the state price files and the brand's own price list in NetSuite
  • Deductions: the retailer remittances, with the 3PL's signed proofs of delivery and the carriers' appointment records
  • Co-packing: the two co-packers' invoices and the tolling agreements behind them

Every billback line was tied to the program it claimed, the depletions it was calculated from and the price in force on the date of sale. Every deduction was tied to the shipment it named and the documents that showed what happened to it.

What Seeft found

FindingLinesAmount
Billbacks that matched no approved program14% of lines$1.6M
Billbacks at a tier the depletions never reached6% of lines$690K
Billbacks billed twice2% of lines$220K
Retailer deductions contradicted by the brand's own records$1.1M
Co-packer yield loss above the tolling allowance$340K
Total identified$3.95M

The retailer deductions were contradicted three ways: a signed proof of delivery showing the full order arrived, a carrier appointment record showing the truck was on time, or a promotion the retailer deducted for that a distributor had already been paid for through a billback.

One billback line, worked through

A distributor billed a $2.40 a case feature allowance on 2,100 cases of sparkling water sold in May, $5,040.

The program letter, found in a sales manager's sent mail, agreed the feature for two weeks in May at $2.40 a case. The distributor's own depletion report showed 2,100 cases sold across the whole month, but only 960 in the two feature weeks. Seeft held the line and drafted the short-pay for the 1,140 cases sold outside the promotion, $2,736, with the program letter and the depletion lines attached. The distributor reissued the billback at $2,304.

Lines like this were the most common finding. Each was small. Across a year and 58 distributors, they made up most of the $1.6M.

How the disputes ran

  • Weeks 1 to 2: connect the sources and load a year of history
  • Weeks 3 to 4: the first findings, sorted by value and by how close each was to its deadline
  • Month 2 onward: every new billback held until it was checked, and every new deduction checked as it landed
  • Throughout: the team approved each dispute before it went out. Retailer deductions were filed inside each retailer's window, starting with the ones closest to closing

What came back

IdentifiedReturned within 12 months
Billbacks$2.51M$1.65M dropped or reissued
Retailer deductions$1.1M$660K reversed
Co-packers$340K$290K credited
Total$3.95M$2.6M

Not everything came back. About $440K of the retailer deductions were older than the retailer's dispute window by the time the check reached them. On about $860K of billbacks, the program had been agreed on a call, and the email trail was too thin to contest. The brand chose not to press those with two of its largest distributors.

What changed

The bigger result was what stopped happening. Once distributors knew every line was checked, the share of billbacks worth disputing fell from 22% to 7%. On $11.2M of billbacks a year, that is about $1.7M a year saved before any dispute is filed.

Sales managers now send every promotion as a program letter from one template. The accountant reviews only the lines Seeft can't settle from the documents. Every outcome, from a short-pay to a reversed deduction, is posted back to NetSuite, so the books show what was actually recovered.

What this would look like for your brand

Every brand's mix of distributors, retailers and paperwork is different. A free audit checks your own recent billbacks and deductions and shows what is recoverable, by retailer, distributor and type, within two weeks of receiving your data.

See what your deductions are hiding

Send us your recent deductions. We’ll show you what’s recoverable in two weeks.