At a glance
| Profile | |
|---|---|
| The manufacturer | Halvorsen Pharmaceuticals, generic injectables and oral solids |
| Sales | $680M gross, $410M net |
| Wholesalers | Three, filing about 38,000 chargeback lines a month |
| Contracts | 58 GPO and IDN contracts, with 212 amendments |
| Rosters | A new membership roster from each purchasing group every month |
| What we checked | 456,000 chargeback lines and four quarters of rebates |
The problem
Halvorsen Pharmaceuticals sells $680M gross and books $410M net. Most of the gap is chargebacks. When a wholesaler sells to a hospital at the price the hospital's purchasing group negotiated, the wholesaler claims the difference back from Halvorsen. Three wholesalers file about 38,000 of those lines a month.
Whether a line is valid depends on three things on the date of sale: which contract the buyer was on, which price tier that contract had reached, and whether the buyer was on the group's roster that day. The answers were spread across 58 contracts, 212 amendments and a monthly roster from each group, all kept as PDFs and spreadsheets on a shared drive.
Checking one line by hand took about 50 minutes. The three-person contracts team reviewed every claim above $2,500 and a small sample of the rest. More than nine in ten lines were credited as claimed.
What the check involved
Seeft built a dated record of every term that decides a chargeback:
- Contracts and amendments: each price, tier and eligibility rule, with the date it took effect and the date it ended
- Rosters: every monthly version from every group, so a buyer's membership could be read for any day of the year
- Price notices: every tier change and price update the groups and wholesalers had sent
- Claims: the wholesalers' EDI 844 chargeback files, line by line, and the rebate statements for each quarter
Then it tested all 456,000 lines from the past 12 months against the terms in force on each line's date of sale, not the terms in force when the claim was filed.
What Seeft found
| Finding | Lines | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Buyers who weren't on the contract that day | 8,900 | $2.7M |
| Prices claimed at a tier that had expired | 5,100 | $1.5M |
| Invoices already credited in an earlier claim | 1,600 | $410K |
| Rebates paid on market share the wholesaler data didn't support | One quarter | $260K |
| Total identified | $4.87M |
Most of the off-contract lines came from roster changes. A hospital leaves a purchasing group at the end of a month, but the wholesaler's system keeps applying the group's price for weeks, sometimes months.
One chargeback line, worked through
A wholesaler claimed a chargeback on 240 vials sold on 14 April to a hospital, at the group's contract price of $18.75 against a list price of $41.20. The claim was $22.45 a vial, $5,388.
The group's April roster, received on 2 April, showed the hospital had left on 31 March. On the date of sale it was not entitled to the contract price. Seeft held the line and drafted the dispute with the roster entry and the contract's eligibility clause attached. Once the contracts team approved it, it went back to the wholesaler with the next batch response, and the wholesaler reversed the credit.
There were 8,900 lines like that one in a single year.
How the disputes ran
- Weeks 1 to 3: the contracts, amendments and rosters read and dated, and a year of claim files loaded
- Week 4: the first findings, grouped by wholesaler and by cause
- Month 2 onward: disputes filed weekly with each wholesaler, with the roster line and contract page attached. New batches were answered inside the 30-day response window. Older lines went through each wholesaler's reconciliation process
- Throughout: nothing went back to a wholesaler until the contracts team approved it
What came back
| Identified | Recovered within 12 months | |
|---|---|---|
| Chargebacks | $4.61M | $3.4M reversed |
| Rebates | $260K | $260K netted against the next payment |
| Total | $4.87M | $3.66M |
About $1.2M did not come back. Some lines were too old for the wholesalers' reconciliation terms. Others turned on rosters a purchasing group could no longer confirm.
What changed
Seeft now reads each roster and price notice the day it arrives, so a claim against an out-of-date term is held before it is credited instead of chased afterwards. The invalid chargeback rate fell from 3.4% of lines to 0.8%, worth about $3.5M a year.
The contracts team no longer samples. It reviews the lines Seeft can't settle from the documents, a few dozen a week, and every outcome is posted back to SAP.
What this would look like for your business
Every manufacturer's contracts, wholesalers and rosters are different. A free audit checks your own recent chargebacks and shows what is recoverable, by wholesaler and cause, within two weeks of receiving your data.