Seeft
ReportsReport

Report · November 2026

The fines that come back

Not every deduction is wrong. Brands told us the valid ones worry them more, because the same fines keep arriving.

Valid isn't the end of it

When a fine is valid, the usual move is to accept it and close the case. But a late delivery, a short-shipped pallet or a mislabeled carton usually has a cause that hasn't gone away: a carrier lane that runs late, a 3PL that picks short, a label template that's wrong, a packaging change that doesn't survive transit. Close the case without fixing that, and the same fine is back next month.

What brands told us

Compliance fines were the charges brands most often described as growing. Several had found patterns only by chance. One traced a run of damage claims back to a change in its packaging. Another found that loads it had documented properly were still drawing shortage and overage chargebacks.

The finance and AR leaders we spoke to wanted the same thing: to know whether a fee came from a particular 3PL, carrier, warehouse or the retailer's own receiving, so they could take it to the right owner. Most said they couldn't do that yet.

Why it's hard

The information sits in different places. AR holds the deduction and the reason code. Operations holds the shipment, the carrier and the warehouse. Logistics partners hold the timestamps. It's no one's job to join them, so patterns stay invisible until they're expensive.

What works

  • Tag every valid fine with its source: retailer, distribution center, carrier, 3PL, warehouse and item
  • Review the top causes every month with the teams that own them, with a dollar value on each
  • Hand partner-caused fines to whoever manages that carrier or 3PL, with the evidence
  • Check whether the fine stops after the fix

Questions to ask your team

  • What were our five most expensive recurring fines last quarter?
  • Do we know which carrier, 3PL or warehouse caused each one?
  • Who owns fixing them?
About this report. Based on our conversations in 2026 with finance, AR and operations leaders at consumer brands. We combine and anonymize what we heard; no brand is named or identifiable.

See what your deductions are hiding

Send us your recent deductions. We’ll show you what’s recoverable in two weeks.