Where the line comes from
A deduction arrives as a code and an amount on a remittance, often with no explanation. To decide whether it's valid, someone has to work out what the code means at that retailer, find the order and the shipment, and check them against an agreement that may live in a contract, an old email or a conversation with a sales rep. If it's wrong, they then need the proof.
That's a lot of work for a $150 claim. So teams do the sensible thing: they set a threshold and accept everything below it. Some of the teams we spoke to had never formally disputed a deduction at all, because they weren't confident enough in their own records to push back. In wine and spirits, where distributors bill suppliers back for deal discounts, we heard the same thing put more bluntly: billbacks get approved to clear the desk, not because anyone has checked them.
What AR software changes, and what it doesn't
Brands running AR software told us the same story in a different way. The tools are good at sorting deductions and suggesting which ones to look at. But the work after that, logging into each retailer's portal, pulling the proof and filing the dispute, is still done by people. So the line stays where it is.
What sits below the line
Small deductions are rarely one-offs. The same shortage code from the same distribution center. The same late-delivery fine on the same carrier lane. Accepted one at a time, they never add up on anyone's desk, and nothing changes in the warehouse that caused them. Below the line is where repeat fines hide.
What changes when checking is cheap
When every deduction can be decoded and matched to its order and shipment automatically, the threshold stops being a necessity. It becomes a choice you can make with numbers: which codes are worth disputing, which are valid and need fixing at the source, and which aren't worth the time.
Questions to ask your team
- Where is our write-off line, and who set it?
- How much did we accept below it last year, by retailer and code?
- How much of that is still inside the retailer's dispute window?
- Which of those deductions keep repeating?